| Tag Team Name | Superstar 1 | Superstar 2 | Superstar 3 | Superstar 4 | Universe Roster |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acolytes Protection Agency | Farooq | JBL | Allstars Show | ||
| Alpha Academy | Chad Gable | Otis | That 80's Show | ||
| Bloodline | Roman Reigns | Jey Uso | Jimmy Uso | Allstars Show | |
| Breezango | Tyler Breeze | Fandango | That 80's Show | ||
| British Strong Style | Pete Dunne | Trent Seven | Tyler Bate | Allstars Show | |
| Catch Point | Timothy Thatcher | Drew Gulak | That 70's Show | ||
| Dirty Dawgs | Dolph Ziggler | Robert Roode | That 80's Show | ||
| Disciples of the Apocolypse | Alexa Bliss | Shotzi | Women's Showcase | ||
| Imperium | Walter | Marcel Barthel | Fabian Aichner | That 70's Show | |
| Legado Del Fantasma | Santos Escobar | Joaquin Wilde | Raul Mendoza | That 70's Show | |
| Lorcan & Burch | Oney Lorcan | Danny Burch | That 70's Show | ||
| Los Lotharios | Humberto Carrillo | Angel Garza | Allstars Show | ||
| Lucha House Party | Kalisto | Lince Dorado | Gran Metalik | That 80's Show | |
| Miz & Morrison | The Miz | John Morrison | That 80's Show | ||
| nWo | Hollywood Hogan | Kevin Nash | Scott Hall | Syxx | Allstars Show |
| Retribution | Mace | T-Bar | Slapjack | That 70's Show | |
| RK-Bro | Randy Orton | Riddle | Allstars Show | ||
| Street Profits | Angelo Dawkins | Montez Ford | Allstars Show | ||
| The Hurt Business | Bobby Lashley | MPV | Allstars Show | ||
| The Iconics | Billie Kay | Peyton Royce | Women's Showcase | ||
| The Mysterios | Rey Mysterio | Dominik Mysterio | That 80's Show | ||
| The New Day | Big E | Kofi Kingston | Xavier Woods | Allstars Show | |
| The Viking Raiders | Erik | Ivar | That 80's Show | ||
| The Way | Johnny Gargano | Austin Theory | That 70's Show | ||
| Toxic Attraction | Mandy Rose | Gigi Dolin | Jacy Jayne | Women's Showcase |
